
California has started several “science of reading” initiatives in recent years, which a panel of education experts polled by the New York Times considers the most cost-effective means for raising student achievement. The experts ranked “science of reading” initiatives as one of the top ideas for fixing US schools.
Implementation is where California falls short, with a state system that is not set up to translate policy into change in the field. Unfortunately, this is the area where California is weakest. Big dollars are being spent, but many reading advocates doubt the results will be meaningful. The ideas are good; the implementation is not.
Comparison with Mississippi
Mississippi’s approach to reading initiatives, known as the “Mississippi Miracle,” has been successful in catapulting the state to the top of national rankings. Both California and Mississippi aim to train current K-2 teachers in the science of reading, but Mississippi identified a single effective training program and required all teachers and administrators to use it.
California, on the other hand, gave schools 31 programs to choose from, or allowed them to pick their own or skip training altogether. This approach has led to concerns that the results may not be meaningful, despite big dollars being spent.
Key Differences
Another key difference between the two states is the use of reading coaches. Mississippi spent three years building a statewide cadre of coaches, vetted and hired by the state, to ensure their science of reading knowledge. California, however, put $500 million into literacy coaches but left their use up to local districts, resulting in many not applying science of reading approaches or even hiring coaches.
Implementation and Local Control
Realizing better outcomes in California doesn’t require discarding local control, but it does require state leaders to see that policies without high standards and state support are a recipe for inequity. Stronger guardrails, such as building stronger connections between Sacramento and local districts, implementation chains”, that spell out exactly how the state makes sure that local districts are following key policies, are needed to ensure that local districts are following key policies.